SIP or fixed deposit: how to compare them honestly
One has a guaranteed return and the other does not. Here is how to put them side by side anyway.
A fixed deposit tells you exactly what you will get. A SIP does not. Comparing them means comparing a certainty with a distribution, and most comparisons quietly skip that.
Start with after-tax, after-inflation
A deposit at seven per cent, taxed at thirty, returns under five per cent. If prices are rising at five, the real return is about zero: the money is safe and is not growing. That is a reasonable trade for an emergency fund and a poor one for a twenty-year goal.
Equity returns are an average of very unlike years
A twelve per cent long-run average is not twelve per cent a year. It is some years of thirty and some of minus twenty. Over three years that spread dominates the result; over fifteen it tends to average out. Time horizon, not temperament, is what should decide the mix.
Sequence matters near the end
Two investors with identical average returns can end with very different sums if the bad years fall in different places. A poor stretch early is recoverable because later instalments buy cheaply. A poor stretch in the last three years hits the whole accumulated balance. This is why money needed soon should be moved out of equity before it is needed, not when it is.
A workable rule
- Money you may need within three years: deposits or liquid funds. Certainty is worth more than a point of return.
- Three to seven years: a mix, weighted by how firm the date is.
- Beyond seven years: equity can carry the weight, provided you will not sell in a bad year.
Run both calculators with the same monthly amount and the same period, then run the SIP again with a return a few points lower. If the lower figure still meets the goal, the plan is robust. If only the optimistic one does, it is not a plan.
Neither calculator includes tax. Deposit interest is taxed every year at your slab; equity gains are taxed when you sell.